Centre :: East :: West :: Oltrarno :: Fiesole
Introduction :: The List :: The Lost


The Lost Churches




Via della Pergola

Lost art
Had The Visitation of Saint Anne by Ghirlandaio, panel painting. (Cadogan p244.) Also two by Francesco Morandini (il Poppi) - a Crucifixion and a Finding of the True Cross, both now in the Andrea del Sarto Cenacolo Museum at San Salvi, where there is also a Gloria di angeli e santi by Giovanni Baldacci.





The Widows' Asylum of Santa Maria in Orbatello was founded in 1372 by Nicholas Alberti to a design, we are told, by Agnolo Gaddi. It was set up to house widows and their children, the numbers of whom were a consequence of Florentine society's tendency to marry young women to older men. Construction was completed by 1378. Upon reaching the age of 36 girls from the Spedale degli Innocenti were sent here too. The oratory of Santa Maria di Orbatello is now the art history library of the University of Florence, the old hospital buildings houses a dermatology clinic.

The church
An aisleless single nave with a slightly raised presbytery and a trussed wood ceiling with painted decoration.

Lost art
An Adoration of the Magi by Ghirlandaio, now in the Pitti, where it was by 1839.
An Annunciation with Saints Nicholas and Anthony Abbot by Giovanni del Biondo is now in the museum of the Ospedale degli Innocenti, as is a triptych of the Virgin and Child with Saints Jerome and Catherine (c.1420) by Giovanni Toscani.  Also there is a fresco panel of the Virgin and Child with Two Seraphs by a follower of Ghirlandaio, probably his brother Davide. It is surrounded by panels showing Christ Blessing with Cherubim and Seraphim and Saints Andrew and Denis, by the Master of the Fiesole Epiphany.


San Benedetto fuori della Porta a Pinti


A smaller offshoot of the Camaldolese convent of Santa Maria degli Angeli, established by seven monks from there, including two members of the Ricci family, possibly partially in opposition to the dominant Albizzi faction. The complex was built on land bought by Don Alessandro dei Ricci just outside the third set of city walls, with help from other donors from the Spini family. The plague of 1400 had left Don Alessandro as the sole heir to the family's estate and the church was built by 1402. Inside the church the chapel of Saint Luke had frescoes and a gold-ground altarpiece. The chapel of St Anthony was added in 1402, funded by the Corso as a private burial space. A campanile and library followed in 1405, the church was consecrated in 1407 and choir stalls and Lorenzo Monaco's Coronation of the Virgin (see right) were installed in 1409. A new cloister followed in 1412. The complex was demolished during the Siege of Florence in 1529/30. Its treasures were moved to Santa Maria degli Angeli, including manuscripts, as well as the altarpieces mentioned below, the Lorenzo Monaco one being moved to the Alberti Chapel in the cloister there, where Vasari saw it.

Lost art
Lorenzo Monaco's Coronation of the Virgin (1407), now in the National Gallery, once stood on the high altar here. This commission presumably not unconnected with his having been a monk at Santa Maria degli Angeli, the monastery from which this community sprang. Predella panels depicting the Adoration of the Magi and Scenes from life St Benedict are in the National Gallery, the Vatican Pinacoteca and the National Museum in Poznań in Poland. Pinnacle panels depicting the Virgin Annunciate, the Prophet Jeremiah and the Blessing Redeemer are in Pasadena, the Feigen Collection and the Accademia. The Four Patriarchs, now in the Met in New York, are more disputed additions.
An altarpiece of 1404 of the Virgin and Child with Saints  by Niccolò di Pietro Gerini is now in the Accademia. The predella depicting scenes from the lives of Saints Lawrence, John the Baptist and Anthony Abbot and a central Adoration of the Magi are in the Feigen Collection, a private collection, Zagreb and the Berlin Gemäldegalerie respectively. This altarpiece was part of an endowment by Domenico di Francesco Corsi, a silk merchant, for the chapel of St Anthony Abbot here.

Nat Gall 15th C vol 1 p 180


San Donato a Scopeto


San Gaggio


This Augustinian complex, just outside the Porta Romana, was demolished during the siege of Florence in 1529/30, as were most buildings outside the walls, so that the attackers couldn't use them for refuge or supplies. The Romanesque portico of this church, possibly 11th-century, is now on the front of San Jacopo sopr'Arno.

Lost art
Leonardo's dramatically unfinished and Flemish-influenced Adoration of the Magi, commissioned in 1481 is now in the Uffizi, as is the less animated but still well-populated panel (finished in March 1496) that the brothers here got Filippino Lippi to paint on the same subject to replace it. It is not known why Leonardo's altarpiece went uncompleted - one theory is that the composition for too unusual for the monks -  or why a commission to Ghirlandaio, before Lippi got the job, proved similarly fruitless. The Leonardo panel underwent a 6-year restoration that was completed in 2017.
Had a large painted Crucifix by Bernardo Daddi, now in the Accademia, and a Last Supper in the refectory by Ghirlandaio
The detached fresco fragment of The Madonna del Parto by Taddeo Gaddi (c. 1355) now in San Francesco di Paola, was taken from the demolished church of San Pier Maggiore, but it is said to have originally been painted for this church.

Lost art
Two panels from a polyptych, Saints Catherine of Alexandria and Caius, of about 1390 by Lorenzo Monaco, his first major commission, are now in the Accademia. The pinnacle with The Coronation of the Virgin (see right) is in the Courtauld*, with predella panels in Berlin (but not to be found in the Gemäldegalerie when I was there) and Santa Barbara.

*But currently (2020) on loan to the National Gallery due to rebuilding work at the Courtauld.


San Gallo


A church dedicated to hermit monk Saint Gallen had existed here since 1218.  In the 15th century the church passed from Franciscans to the reformed Augustinians at the instigation of Lorenzo de 'Medici who got the architect Giuliano Giamberti to expand the church and monastery. Work on the new building was underway by 1488 and reported as 'almost finished' in 1493. This work so impressed Lorenzo that he, as reported by Giorgio Vasari, nicknamed the architect Sangallo, and thereafter his Giamberti descendants kept the name da Sangallo. This was the one major ecclesiastical commission that Lorenzo financed himself. The complex was demolished during the siege of Florence in 1529-1530, as were most buildings outside the walls, so that the attackers couldn't use them for refuge or supplies. 
An early-14th-century inventory lists a 'little old church with an altar and a sacristy next to the said church and a bell tower with four large bells' and 'another new church near to the old church with the piazza in between. In the detail from the Catena map of 1471-80 (see right) the old church must be the building to the right, under the word GALLO, with the new church's portico, it is presumed, to the left.

Lost art
Fra Bartolomeo's Lamentation was painted for San Gallo, moved to San Jacopo tra Fossi, and is now  in the Palatine Gallery in the Palazzo Pitti.
The Noli me Tangere by Andrea del Sarto (see right), is one of three altarpieces that he painted around 1510 for San Gallo. It too was moved to San Jacopo tra Fossi, and is now in the museum in the refectory at San Salvi, which also houses Andrea's famous Cenacollo. The other two were a Disputation on the Trinity (widely thought by his contemporaries to be one of his masterpieces) and an impressive and  architectural Annunciation, with the angel unusually on the right, both now in the Pitti. The Annunciation, having been initially commissioned by Taddeo di Dante da Castiglione for San Gallo, moved to another chapel belonging to the same family in San Jacopo tra Fossi, before Maria Magdalena of Austria had it brought to decorate her bedchamber at the Pitti in 1627.
The Virgin and Child with Saints Francis and Zenobius (1510) by Francesco Granacci (see left) from the Gerolami chapel here, is now in the Accademia, where this prolific artist, the son of a mattress maker, apprentice to Ghirlandaio and friend of Michelangelo, has quite a few works in the early rooms.


San Giovanni Evangelista

The church of a convent founded by the Vallombrosan nun Umiltà (Humility or Humilitas) of Faenza in 1282. She is said to have founded the Vallombrosan female order and died here in 1310. The complex was demolished during the siege of Florence in 1529-1530, as were most buildings outside the walls, so that the besiegers couldn't use them for refuge or supplies. 
Much of its surviving art depicts Umiltà with a weasel, the enemy of the serpent, symbol of evil. This animal was replaced as her attribute in later art by a book, and that too vanished in Counter-Reformation depictions, in which she becomes a generic saint without distinguishing symbols
(On the Chain Map)


Lost art
All but two of the panels from the Altarpiece of the Blessed Humilitas by Pietro Lorenzetti are in the Uffizi. The other two, depicting Saint Humility Cures a Sick Nun and The Ice Miracle of Saint Humility are in the Gemäldegalerie in Berlin. In the Uffizi the central panel shows the Blessed Humility and the predella  panels show eleven stories from her life. Vasari said that it was by Buffalmacco.

San Girolamo delle Poverine
photo flo sept 2012 thurs 1346 and entry for Sant'Onofrio di Fuligno in West

San Gregorio alla Pace
Convent, now part of Museo Bardini.

San Giusto alle Mura

This Jesuit monastery was just outside the Porta a Pinti, a northern gate. It had two cloisters frescoed by Perugino and was demolished during the siege of Florence in 1529-1530, as were most buildings outside the walls, so that the attackers couldn't use them for refuge or supplies. 

Lost art

Perugino's calm Pietà and his The Agony in the Garden were painted c. 1493-96 for chapels in the rood screen of this church. The Pietà is notable for its lavish use of expensive ultramarine, a pigment which the prior here was said to have been skilled at preparing. Following demolition both were taken to San Giovannino della Calza near the Porta Romana, but have ended up in the Uffizi.

San Miniato fra le Torre

Was in the area now occupied by the central Post Office, the church was demolished in 1785.

Lost art
Assumption of the Virgin by Andrea del Castagno in the Gemäldegalerie in Berlin.

San Niccolò di Cafaggio   San Pier Buonconsiglio


A Benedictine convent built by Niccolò Gianfigliazzi in 1340 and suppressed in 1783. It stood on what is now the via degli Alfani and was named for the Cafaggio area, which then was woods. Also called San Niccolò in via del Cocomero, for the previous name of the current via Ricasoli. The remaining convent complex now houses the Opificio delle Pietre Dure and the Academy of Fine Arts.

Lost art
A high altarpiece polyptych by Bicci di Lorenzo, with the help of Stefano d’Antonio di Vanni, from c.1433, dismembered a sold off in 1787. The central panel of the Virgin and Child with Four Angels is now in the Galleria Nazionale, Parma. It was flanked on the left by a panel depicting Saints Benedict and Nicholas of Bari now in the Museo del Monumento Nazionale della Badia Greca, Grottaferrata (this panel is ascribed to Stefano d’Antonio) and on the right by a panel representing Saints John the Baptist and Matthew, now in the Met in New York. The predella probably had seven panels of the life of Saint Nicholas, of which six have been identified. These panels are said to be The Birth of Saint Nicholas (sold at Sotheby’s in July 2009, current whereabouts unknown), The Miracle of a Child Restored to his Parents (up for auction, Dorotheum 10th November 2020), Saint Nicholas Providing Dowries and Saint Nicholas Resuscitating Three Youths (both in The Met New York), Saint Nicholas Rescuing Sailors in a Storm (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford),  and A Miracle at the Tomb of Saint Nicholas (Wawel State Collection, Kraków).


Painted by Fabio Borbottoni, below.


San Pier Maggiore
Borgo degli Albizzi


Tradition has it that Saint Zenobius, Florence's 4th-century first bishop and later one of the city's patron saints, had founded a church here in the 5th century. The first documented mention of the complex, though, is of a Benedictine convent, founded in 1067, with Ghisla Firidoli as its first abbess. The abbess traditionally welcomed each new bishop of Florence upon his arrival in the city, with a ceremony involving putting a ring on his finger. She was therefore nicknamed 'the wife of the bishop'.
The Gothic church was built during enlargement in the early 14th century, being completed by 1352. It was a large triple-aisled church with the high altar (upon which would have stood the large altarpiece by Jacopo di Cione mentioned below) in a large raised choir chapel that was rebuilt 1612-15, around which time the altarpiece was removed. After a lot of minor rebuildings it was rebuilt in 1638 by Matthew Nigetti as seen in the etching  and plan (see right).
Among the artists buried here were Lorenzo di Credi, Luca della Robbia, Piero di Cosimo and Mariotto Albertinelli.
The church was demolished in 1784 having been declared unsafe following a partial collapse during rebuilding work the year before, which had itself been prompted by a crumbling column, but only one, non-load bearing, column had collapsed. Supposedly the real reason for the demolition was Grand Duke Peter Leopold's desire to minimize the dominance of religious institutions in Florence which had been behind his many suppressions.
Three arches of the portico (part of the 1638 rebuilding) of the façade survive (see photo right), two being occupied by private houses. Art and fittings from the church were transferred to various Florentine institutions, including the Spedale degli Innocenti and the church of San Michele Visdomini.

Lost art
A marble high relief of the Annunciation by Arnolfo di Cambio from c.1295/1302 is in the V&A in London. It was formerly in the cloister here.
An early 14th century painted Crucifix by Lippo di Benivieni is now in the Santa Croce museum, where it's been since 1785.
The majority of the 12-panel Coronation of the Virgin high altarpiece of 1370-71, by Jacopo di Cione (see below), commissioned for this church, probably by the Albizzi family, is now in the National Gallery in London. The main panel is flanked by two large panels of crowds of saints, with a substantial group of six panels depicting scenes from The Life of Christ above. The frame is lost and the predella, showing scenes from the Life of Saint Peter, and pilaster panels have been identified in other collections.

The Assumption of the Virgin of c. 1475-6 by Francesco Botticini, which was the altarpiece in the burial chapel here of the humanist Matteo Palmieri, is now in the National Gallery in London. He and his wife flank the apostles who stand around the Virgin's rose-filled tomb in the lower section. The mixing up Old Testament figures, future saints and the six lower orders of saints is said to illustrate Palmieri's heretical writings, most oddly holding that humankind descended from neutral angels at the time of Lucifer's fall. This explains why his face had been defaced by scratches before recent restoration. His body was also removed from the church later and an effigy of him burned. The work had been previously thought to be by Botticelli, due to Vasari confusing their names.
In 2015 there was an exhibition at the National Gallery devoted to the Botticini Assumption of the Virgin, with connections made to the Jacopo di Cione altarpiece also in the National Gallery. Research involved trying to reconstruct San Pier Maggiore, and there's a fascinating film.
Watch it here
The Madonna of the Girdle by Francesco Granacci (1508/9) looks very Michelangelo-inspired and is now in the Accademia.
The Visitation by Maso da San Friano, a Mannerist altarpiece of 1560 painted for the chapel of the de' Pesci in this church, is now in the Fitzwilliam in Cambridge UK.
An Annunciation by Giovanni Antonio Sogliani, taken from this church when it closed in 1783, was installed behind the high altar in the 1910s to replace Ghirlandaio's Adoration of the Magi in the church of the Spedale degli Innocenti.
The third work from this church in the National Gallery in London is Saint Zenobius Revives a Dead Boy by Giovanni Bilivert from c.1610/20. It depicts the same miracle as featured in the works sited below, and also includes a view of the façade of this church. Bilivert, born in Florence, the son of a Dutch goldsmith, worked for the Medici and was the most successful pupil of Florentine Baroque artist Lodovico Cigoli. Bilivert painted this large panel for his friend Giuliano Girolami, who came from a prominent Florentine banking family who claimed descent from Zenobius. The family’s coat of arms appears on the clasp of the saint’s cope.

The church in art
Saint Zenobius, the first bishop of Florence, is said to have performed one of his miracles on a procession from San Pier Maggiore to the Duomo after a cart ran over a boy, so the church appears in the background of many paintings of this miracle. The original church is visible in the background of Saint Zenobius Raising a Boy from the Dead (see right) by Ridolfo Ghirlandaio. And
A Miracle of Saint Zenobius by Domenico Veneziano in the Fitzwilliam, Cambridge UK, part of the St Lucy Altarpiece. Also Saint Zenobius Resuscitating a Dead Child by Benozzo Gozzoli in the MET New York. The church in Masaccio and Masolino's Saint Peter Healing with His Shadow fresco in the Brancacci Chapel may also be, somewhat appropriately, San Pier Maggiore.
There's a late 19th century view painting by Fabio Borbottoni of this church.




The original 14th-century church as held by
Saint Peter in the Jacopo di Cione altarpiece.

San Pier Martire
via dei Serragli

The church and convent was founded in March 1417, the first nunnery founded by the Observant Dominicans, who were keen to return to the order's original values. The complex, the first in Florence to be dedicated to one of the order's most illustrious preachers - who had preached in Florence in 1244 - benefited from the patronage of humanist statesman Niccolò da Uzzano and was built in the former palace of Niccolò Buondelmonte. Two experienced nuns were sent to educate the new nuns here in 1419. They came from San Domenico in Pisa, the same house that had helped set up, and remained closely connected with, the Observant Dominican Corpus Domini in Venice. Amongst the first nuns where Margherita deli Spini and Maddalena di Bartolommeo degli Usimabardi, both from prominent and wealthy families and both of whose name saints feature in the early Fra Angelico altarpiece soon commissioned, so encouraging theories that they were the major donors.
 In 1557 the monastery was closed and demolished to make way for the fortifications around the San Pier Gattolino gate. The nuns here moved to San Felice in Piazza, taking their Fra Angelico altarpiece (see below) with them.

Lost art
Fra Angelico painted the high altarpiece for the church of the monastery, called the San Pietro Martire Altarpiece, c.1421/2 (see right). The main panel, The Virgin and Child with Saints Dominic, John the Baptist, Peter Martyr and Thomas Aquinas is now in the Museum of San Marco. In the roundels are the Annunciation and God the Father, with scenes of Peter Martyr preaching and his assassination in the spandrels. The three predella panels are in the Courtauld Institute in London. They make up seven roundels - the central trio show Christ as the Man of Sorrows flanked by Saint Mary Magdalene and Saint John the Evangelist with flanking pairs of female saints - Saints Catherine of Alexandra and Agnes and The Blessed Margaret of Hungary (Saint Catherine of Siena?) and Saint Cecilia(?).
There's also a painting by Gherardo di Giovanni del Fora in the Bowdoin College Museum in Maine of Saints Mary Magdalene, Peter Martyr and Catherine of Siena (c. 1475) that may well have been painted for the convent here
, not least because of its choice of saints.


San Pier Scheraggio
Via della Ninna


A Romanesque basilica, consecrated in 1068, restored in 1294, and reconsecrated in 1299, which had been used up until the construction of Palazzo Vecchio in 1313 for the City Councils of the Florentine Republic, at which Dante (who lived nearby) and Boccaccio were amongst the speakers. The arches of the left nave, destroyed in 1410 when Via della Ninna was enlarged, are visible from the street (see photo left). The church takes its name from the schiaraggio, or drain that ran beside the city walls. Giorgio Vasari, when he began work on the Uffizi in 1560, demolished/incorporated the church into the building.
After the confiscation of ecclesiastical properties carried out by the Lorena in 1743, the church was deconsecrated, partially demolished and partially incorporated into the Uffizi 1782. The nave still exists and was restored in 1971 but is not open to the public. The church's hall is used to display detached frescoes, including
several from this church and Andrea del Castagno's series of Famous Men from Villa Carducci at Legnaia, (including Danta and Boccaccio) of around 1450. Also fragments of Roman-period decorations of a room that is thought to have been a tavern, discovered under San Pier Scheraggio during the 1971 restoration work.
Francesco d’Angelo (1446-1488), also known as Il Cecca, a Florentine sculptor and engineer, best known for his sculptures - often mechanical - carried in religious processions, theatrical machinery, and military devices. He was killed in battle in 1488 while accompanying the Florentine army and was buried here.

Villani said
In his Chronicles Giovanni Villani says that Florence was constructed in the image of early Christian Rome, with the position of its churches reflecting the pilgrimage churches of Rome. He claims that this church stood in for Old Saint Peters.

Lost art
There were once frescoes by Cimabue in the nave, it is said.
Giovanni dal Ponte's San Piero Scheraggio predella, of around 1430, is now in the Uffizi.
A late-12th-century pulpit, disassembled during the transformations carried out by Vasari in 1570, went to San Leonardo in Arcetri in 1782.
Ridolfo Ghirlandaio's Virgin and Child with Saints Julian and Sebastian was transferred from here to San Martino della Scala in the early 19th century.

The church in art
Vasari's The Procession of Pop Leo X through the Piazza della Signoria, a ceiling panel in the Palazzo Vecchio, has this church in the centre-left background, as does a painting of Savonarolla getting his comeuppance which is in the Pitti Palace's Gallery of Modern Art. And an even better view of the church's façade appears in a late-19th-century painting by Fabio Borbottoni (see detail right)

San Ruffillo


First documented in 1077 and named for the bishop saint of Forlimpopoli. It first faced the small Piazza Cavallari, but in 1620 was reorientated with its entrance on the Piazza dell'Olio. With the suppressions of 1785 it was put to residential use and then demolished in 1823.

Lost art

Pontormo's fresco of a Sacra Conversazione, now in Santissima Annunziata.



San Ruffillo is in the centre, before its reorientation, with San Salvatore al Vescovo to its right and Santa Maria Maggiore to the left. From the Buonsignori Map.




San Tommaso

Originally built in the 13th century by the Sizii family. T
he church was in Piazza del Mercato Vecchio, before the clearance of the Mercato and the Florence Ghetto to make room for the Piazza Vittorio Emanuele II, today called the Piazza della Repubblica. The site of the church, on the north-east corner of the Piazza, is now the Hotel Savoy.

The 1926 postcard (below right) produced by architect Corinto Corinti shows the
the façade of the 13th century church 'compared to the bulk of the building of the Savoy Hotel. The change in scale and character of the building is evident: the articulated and picturesque facade of the old church... gives way to a pretentious and massive building, destined for privileged users.'

The church in art

The church appears in at least two late-19th-century view paintings by Fabio Borbottoni (see below), he having painted much of the Mercato Vecchio just before it was demolished.



A church had been here since the early 9th century, with a convent dedicated to the Virgin. Around the year 1000 the nuns moved to San Martino a Mensola and were replaced by Cluniac monks. In 1013 Bishop Ildebrando gave the complex to the new abbey of San Miniato al Monte and in 1205 the buildings were passed on to secular clergy by Bishop Lamberto.
By the 14th century the Elisei family were patrons. The church was damaged by fires  in 1232, 1304 (during conflict between rival families) and 1601, resulting in restorations. More restoration followed in the 18th century, including the façade.
Suppressed in 1765 and later disgracefully demolished. The church stood on the corner of Calimala and via Pellicceria
before the clearance of the area to make room for the Piazza Vittorio Emanuele II, today called the Piazza della Repubblica.

The church had three altars. The one on the left had an altarpiece by Vasari, but we don't know who painted the one on the right. The high altarpiece was by Domenico Ghirlandaio.

Had been used to house pigeons for a while, with the bells transferred to a more modern tower. The original, somewhat squat, tower was probably 11th century

The church in art
The church appears in at least four late-19th-century view paintings by Fabio Borbottoni (see one of them left), he having painted much of the Mercato Vecchio just before it was demolished. The 1927 postcard (below) was produced by architect Corinto Corinti.




Santa Cecilia
Piazza della Signoria

Opposite the Palazzo Vecchio, built in 1341 where there had been a church since the 9th century, although the first documented mention dates to 929.  Damaged by the same fire which burned down Orsanmichele, along with the rest of the centre, on June 10, 1304, but swiftly rebuilt. Moved in 1367 to enlarge the piazza. Suppressed in 1783 and later demolished. The site of the church is now
the Palazzo Lawison(?) The church is remembered in the naming of the small Piazza di Santa Cecilia behind.

Lost art
Saint Cecilia and Eight Stories from her Life by the Saint Cecilia Master (see right). This altar frontal, from the church of Santa Cecilia, is today generally dated shortly after 1304; it is the work of an anonymous master who may have worked with Giotto at Assisi. Vasari thought that it was by Cimabue. It's now in the Uffizi.

An altarpiece of 1641 by Francesco Curradi of The Death of Saint Cecilia now in Santo Stefano al Ponte.

The church in art
A painting by Giuseppe Zocchi called Piazza della Signoria of c.1741, now in a private collection, shows Santa Cecilia to the right (see detail left). I think that it must be the second doorway beyond the archway, under the bell tower. In the late 19th century a very similar view was painted by Fabio Borbottoni.


From the 1584 Buonsignori Map.


Santa Maria degli Ughi
Piazza Strozzi


Santa Maria delle Campora


church was founded in the ninth century and was perhaps best known for its bell, which rang at three in the morning to signal the finish of work in the Old Market. It also famously rang on the night of 11 December 1529, during the siege of Florence, signalling the sortie of the Florentine militia. During construction of Santa Maria del Fiore, the church of Santa Maria degli Ughi functioned as the cathedral. The Ughi were one of the oldest families in Florence and also gave their name to Montughi at Careggi, where they had the country estate.
church was deconsecrated in 1785 and was later used by the Strozzi as a private chapel. It was demolished in the late nineteenth century as part of the demolition of the Old Market area. The Palazzo Mattei
stands on the site of the old church.

The church in art
Two view paintings by Fabio Borbottoni (1820-1902) of Piazza delle Cipolle (as the Piazza Strozzi was then called) show the Strozzi Palace on the left and this church on the right.


Standing just outside the Porta San Piero Gattolini, this church had a 'very beautiful' choir of walnut decorated with intarsia work. It was another church that was outside the city walls and was destroyed by German soldiers during the siege of 1530.


Lost art

Filippino Lippi's 1485-87 The Virgin Appearing to Saint Bernard of Clairvaux (see below), now in the del Pugliese family chapel in the Badia, was originally painted for their family chapel here.  The Accademia has a Coronation of the Virgin Surrounded by Saints and Angels by Rossello di Jacopo Franchi.

Santa Maria della Neve
The Murate
via Ghibellina


Built as the Santissima Annunziata alle Murate and Santa Caterina convent from 1439 for the Benedictine nuns who had moved from crumbling cells (murate means 'walled up') on the Rubaconte Bridge, which was where the Ponte alle Grazie is now. A poor woman called Appolonia had first walled herself into a small house on the second pier on the bridge in 1390. She was joined by other women and in 1413 they were pressured into becoming Beandictines and called Le Romite dell'Annunziata. In 1424 there were thirteen women and they moved to a house on this site this site. At first the parish and Benedictine convent of Sant'Ambrogio placed restriction on the size, number of chapels and use of the church here, called Santa Maria della Neve. But in 1434 a papal bull disconnected the convent from the parish and allowed the abbess more autonomy. So there were soon plans to enlarge the convent buildings to accommodate the growing number of nuns, now numbering thirty-six.
Work was underway when Giovanni D'Amerigo Benci approached the abbess, Scholastica Rondinelli, with a view to endowing a chapel. Benci, a Medici bank employee, was Cosimo de' Medici's most trusted deputy and, following his return to Florence in 1435, was to become the convent's major early patron. He initially undertook the financing of three altars for the church, with altarpieces by Filippo Lippi, as detailed in Lost art below. In the late 1440s/early 1450s he paid for considerable expansion and rebuilding to house the now exceeding one hundred nuns. His granddaughter Ginevra, the subject of a famous Leonardo portrait, stayed here prior to her unfortunate marriage, and after her death was vested as a nun and buried here.
The complex was further renovated and expanded first in 1471, after a fire, and in 1571 following a flood, this latter rebuilding having provided the church with it's most recent façade, traditionally(!) ascribed to Michelangelo. Documents show that Lorenzo de' Medici financed the early 1470s construction work, but coats of arms and such announcing his involvement were consciously avoided. Caterina de'Medici stayed here from 1528 to 1530 when Queen of France and, after the death of Cosimo I in 1574, so did Camilla Martelli, his second wife. Also the illegitimate daughters of Don Pietro de 'Medici.
Suppressed by the French in 1808, the convent was rebuilt by the architect Domenico Giraldi in 1845 and turned into a prison after the closing of the nearby Stinche and the Bargello in the mid-1800s, which it remained until 1985. During World War II the prison became notorious for the imprisonment and torture of partisans captured by the fascists. Much damage to the church during the flood of 1966, with prisoners having to be rescued by locals.
Following the building of the new lily-shaped Sollicciano prison in the mid-1980s the Murate has been jazzily restored and transformed into housing units, shops, and restaurants, with pedestrian spaces and a piazza named after the chapel of Santa Maria della Neve. The plans were drawn up by Renzo Piano in 1998 and the complex opened in 2011, although some parts remain unfinished.

Miracle-working images
An image of the nursing Virgin was said to have cured a nun's illiteracy when she prayed before it. The convent also possessed a similarly miraculous Annunciation in the sacristy, said to have been the painting brought from the church on the Ponte Rubiconte and now lost, and a Crucifixion by Neri di Bicci.
A marble relief called the Madonna della Neve, attributed to Desiderio da Settignano or Donatello, floated out of the medical dispensary during a flood and came to rest in an orchard. This was interpreted as showing that the image was desirous of a more  place of display. The image was placed in the convent walls before Duke Alessandro de' Medici took responsibility for the image and had the oratory, with no internal passage to the nunnery, built to house it

Lost art
A Filippo Lippi  Annunciation (c.1443) (see left) features a young angel in the doorway to the left, said to represent an angel who regularly appeared to the nuns here. It was painted for the high altar in the church, is now in the Alte Pinakothek in Munich. Lippi painted three altarpieces for this church, another was dedicated to Saint Bernard and is reported to have been destroyed in a flood in 1547. However it has been suggested that a very damaged panel in the MET museum in New York depicting Saints Augustine and Francis, a Bishop Saint, and Saint Benedict might be a surviving fragment from this second altarpiece.  Both works by Lippi were financed by Giovanni d’Amerigo Benci, using his boss Cosimo de'Medici's favoured artist. The third was a Crucifixion, now lost.
There's a Raphaelesque Virgin and Child by Ridolfo del Ghirlandaio, now to be found in the Sant'Onofrio di Fuligno refectory which was originally in the convent here.
The Last Supper by Giorgio Vasari, on five wooden panels, was moved from here to San Marco after suppression, and to the Castellani Chapel in Santa Croce in 1815. In the 1880s it was moved to the former refectory there, after it was decided to make it a museum. It was much damaged during the 1966 flood, having remained submerged for 12 hours, and underwent restoration (funded by the Getty Foundation) from 2010 at the Opificio delle Pietre Dure. It had been put into storage after the flood due to a lack of funds, a situation exposed by Marco Ferri in November 2003. The restoration was completed and the restored painting was returned to the refectory at Santa Croce in 2016.
Vasari also made a painting of The Annunciation for the Murate, in payment for his sister's dowry here. He wrote that he had maybe made the Virgin look a bit too terrified.

Santa Maria della Pace


Santa Maria in Verzaia


The church was built on the site of a chapel just outside the city walls destroyed during the siege of 1530. Consecrated in 1573 as Santa Maria della Neve and later dedicated to Santa Maria della Pace. Part of a monastery which passed in 1616 to the monks of Saint Bernard of Clairvaux. Later abandoned, and then converted to private accommodation in the 19th century. Demolished with the transfer of the Italian capital from Turin to Florence, when it became necessary to create new royal stables. These stables later became the current Art Institute.

The church in art
Painted by Fabio Borbottoni in the late 19th century (see below).

From the Buonsignori map of 1584



Church and monastery, on the Via Pisana just outside the San Frediano gate (approximately nos. 1-3-5-7 now) the church was founded by the Bostichi family.
In the 14th century nuns of the Augustinian order of Santa Maria and San Paolo settled in the monastery having abandoned their monastery of San Paolo alla Casellina in Settimo. In 1483 the patronage of the church passed from the Bostichi family to the Pucci. The complex was one of those destroyed during the siege of 1529 for defensive purposes.

The church in art
Painted by Fabio Borbottoni in the late 19th century (see below).
This suggests that the church survived until then as an oratory.


Santa Maria Sopr'Arno


Santa Maria sul Prato

Also known as Santa Maria dei Bardi, this church is first documented in 1181. It was rebuilt in 1210, paid for by Bardi family. A plaque on the façade read "Fuccio mi feci" and the date 1229, which had to have been the date of a restructuring, not the building, which misled Vasari. The church was closed on 13 May 1785 and the building, which was side-on to the river, was demolished in 1869 during work on the widening of the embankments.

Lost art

The strange devil-bashing Virgin of Succour (1593) by Jacopo Chimento (Empoli) was in the Barcagali-Perucci chapel here. It's now in the Palatine Gallery in the Palazzo Pitti.

The church in art

There is a painting of the church by Telemaco Signorini (see left) commissioned by the descendants of the Bardi family and painted shortly before its demolition.

The church in literature
The 120th of the stories in the Trecentonovelle (300 stories) by Franco Sacchetti  (c.1335-1400).


Lost art

Francesco Brina Adoration of the Magi with one magus looking a bit like Michelangelo,
is in the Andrea del Sarto Cenacolo Museum at San Salvi.








 Centre :: East :: West :: Oltrarno :: Fiesole